Plenty of good ideas poorly implemented

Plenty of good ideas poorly implemented

The Guild 2: Renaissance (computer game)

Customer Review

I was a big fan of the Fugger 2, the guild and the guild 2 and was happy mad on this addon patch thingy here. I have now played 2 rounds, including one in Multiplayer.

In principle, the guild 2 renaissance as the guild 2 with the addon Pirates of the Seas. However, a lot has changed, and (at least so it feels at) thrown completely untested on the market.

The most noticeable change is the economic system. Here fall to 2 terrible innovations.

1. There are on the market square nurnoch things that were actually sold there. Sounds like a logical and exciting change, but turns out to be a huge mistake out! The reason for this lies in the raw materials -> Am Marktplatz are hardly one to get. Who will, for example, opens a tavern by the end of 1 year have no more wheat. Who now thinks "Ok, then I'll stop on a hoof and produzier which" is wrong wrapped -> This can now only produce from expansion-stage 2 wheat .... For roast beef one now needs fish (for whatever reason) - on some maps but no water for fishing -> on the market there are also no antüprlich ....
Who opens a bakery needs flour (which of course does not exist on the market) and must now also open a mill next to the farm. This, however, is not matched by the production forth to the bakery - for a bakery need 3 mills !!

2. Man earns less and everything costs more. With six plants (!) You all self-administered (The AI ​​management can not cope with the changes) earns you when It is practiced properly, ca 5000-7000 the round net. That's when the new prices hardly any money! (The title of free citizens (1 over citizens) will cost 25,000)

The new Office system works at all. The reason is easily found: One can now apply to the lowest level as "yeoman" (new title), but for all items must be above it "civil". This title is so expensive (10,000 - that's in Renaissance more than in Guild 2!) That nobody has this item. Ergo Sum are (except the king and the lowest 2 offices) basically all the offices empty (up to 10 ...)
Thus the entry into the official career is almost impossible, because the king is a principle voted first Miess. But the king has a right to vote on all the offices and because the upper offices are not occupied, he is the only one with the right to vote.

The new school system is bugged (Vers. 4.1) -> Frequently, the children, when they are taken up by the school / training in the list, aslo you want to play with iuhnen, not moving, all these children are then (of all dynasties !) at a location on the map and do nothing.

The AI ​​is also not able to adapt to changes. Who the "Prosperity graph" after 20 years looks at looks that has survived of 6 players at most a the first 2-3 years.

Among the "new, four times as large maps" -> Here too much really is promised. There are the old guild 2 cards Hanse cards and a handful uninspierierte, boring cards which besitzten partially only one city (4 not have counted ...?) (But a huge hinterland;))

"Old" problems were still not behobe. The rich nobleman Dr. XYZ, etc Bishop gets still proposed at the suitors only unfree, Central and unemployed ....

In conclusion: The game has a lot of good ideas, but the implementation is so sad that I can not give buy rating (yet?). Dear the guild 2 with the addon Pirates of the Seas.

Not a good price-performance ratio Rank: 1/5
September 26
Good Bumper Rank: 5/5
November 23
Handy camera very easy to operate Rank: 4/5
September 21
Piano method Rank: 4/5
November 2
Good product 720 Rank: 4/5
May 13
Perfect 1 11464 Rank: 5/5
March 19

Related Reviews


Virobi - Good idea - Poor implementationVileda 136135 Virobi - dusting robot with electrostatic Staubpads (household goods) NHL 13: Plenty of good ideas, poorly executed.NHL 13 Stanley Cup Collector's Edition (Exclusive to Amazon.de) (Video Game) Good idea - poorly implementedAugust MB300 - Clock radio - MP3 player / stereo - Clock radio - AUX input / card reader / USB input / 2x3W speakers / Built-in Rechargeable Battery (Electronics) Good idea, poor implementationBAAS USB OUTLET 1A USB2 (Electronics) Good idea, poor implementation of improvementDevolo dLAN TV Sat Starter Set (SAT TV via the mains, embarrassed no cable, powerline) White (Electronics) Good idea, poor implementation in detailclip-close the patented Mini door closers, White (Kitchen) Good idea, poor workmanshipWolfcraft dowel in the storage case, 4645000 (tool) Good approach poor implementationBrita water filter XXL Optimax Cool 8.5 liters, white (household goods) Good thinking, poorly implementedTrixie 6257 nylon bottom for Freilaufgehege # 6250/6253, Black (Misc.) Good Idea; not implemented idealMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard 4000 Keyboard with cord black / silver (German keyboard layout, QWERTY) (Accessories) Good approach, poor implementation - there are better choicesThinkTank Hydrophobia 70-200 (Camera) Good idea, bad implementationSonos Playbar: TV Soundbar and Wireless speaker for music streaming (wireless controllable with iPhone, iPad, iPod, Kindle, Android), black (Electronics) Good idea - unloving implementedAcer MWA2 MHL Wireless LAN Adapter / Dongle White (Electronics) Good basic idea poorly implementedZenker 7515 Pizza Baker Set 4 pcs. Teflon® (household goods) Good idea, poorly constructed!Catit 50695 litter box with cover Jumbo (Misc.) Good idea - boring implementationKeepers of Memory - The Giver (Amazon Instant Video) Children camera - good idea, flawed implementationLexibook DJ045DC Disney Cars Digital Camera (0.3 MP, 32MB internal memory) (electronic) Good idea! Implementation satisfactory ....LunchBots Uno (household goods) Good idea, not implemented perfectly.Pellor shoulder stand shoulder brace DSLR DSLR Rig Shoulder Mount Support for DV Camera Sony Canon 5D 7D etc (Electronics)