Scan quality is insufficient

Scan quality is insufficient

Rollei PDF-S 330 Pro Slide / Negative Scanner (9 megapixels, 6.9 cm (2.7 inch) display) (Personal Computers)

Customer Review

The device has some good features, but is insufficient in the scan quality. The scans look regularly as were formerly been disfigured by post with too much contrast enhancement and sharpening good digital images. Although a simple scan takes only 2-3 seconds, but with switched MagicTouch to "dust and scratch removal" jumps the time to 45 sec high!

The device is almost cubical with a floor area between A4 and wide along, and looks very bulky, but is then more easily than expected. The size and fine workmanship makes it stable.

A thick handbook in postcard format is. But that is only because so thick because scarce information is repeated in 16 languages. Little more is done than content to print options that I can see anyway, if I use the appliance. What the options are, and how to use them, is not explained. For example, I'm still not clear what the choice of a "resolution" of "very high, high, normal" of the "size" of "12M, 9M, 5M, 1M" is different. The sensor is natively 9M (megapixel) resolution have, so why interpolations to me not obvious are offered to even greater numbers of pixels. This, as well as the reduction of the number of pixels, could better be made on the computer, if necessary. (The choice of the resolution had hardly any influence on the image size -. Extremes in complex images were 1.5MB "very high" in and 1.3MB at "Normal" The choice of size had more effect, but decreased from 100% at "9M" only about 20% of "1M" back.)

The device can scan slides and negatives in 36x24mm format (135 film) and in the 60x45 and 60x60mm format (120 films), as well as paper prints (10x15cm up). I've tested all sizes.

The uniformity of illumination was good in all cases.

Dias:
A holder for slides in 5x5cm format is. This is unlocked, opened, and then the slides are inserted into precisely fitting shells, folded, the frame and locked. It can be inserted thin glassless frame and thick frame with glass, and even mixed. The images were always satisfactory focus. The bars are very important to the fixed slide holder, but unfortunately making a measly impression.

With 8 ways to insert a slide connected to the 4 ways to push the frame into the machine comes to a bit of confusion. Only one of the 32's right ;-). The label with arrows on all corners of the frame, combined with orientation logo only on the outside of the frame - therefore not visible if you have opened the frame - is unhelpful.

A built-in Magic Touch function allows lint, scratches to remove inter alia out of the picture. The location of the lint is usually replaced with the color of the side area, but sometimes only with gray. But that still fits better than the deep black of lint. Overall, it works surprisingly well - not always but often - both with glassless and glass slides (and even with 135 negatives).

Only: the scanning time is 2-3 seconds without MT to 45 MT sec with high! This restriction allows the workflow drop significantly. Neither in promotional materials even in the manual should be noted.

The scans I have projected via projector, while the slides by classic projector. The quality defects were abundantly clear. Bright image areas (clouds in the sky, bright clothes) are virtually structureless white, dark areas (objects in shadows, evening mood) to structure timeless black. Only for images with low cut-off differences, the scans were acceptable.

Negative:
Another frame similar to the slides allows the insertion of a strip of up to 6 negatives. Again, there is the challenge of finding the correct orientation! Inside, the frame on one side guide rails, between which one can keep the negatives, on the other hand a flat lid. Only: all my negatives have a mild curvature, and this must be for the correct side correctness down. But then the film edges are higher than the guide rails, and are being held by those NOT! As a result, the strips slipping when closing the holder, so that several frustrating attempts for correct positioning are usually necessary. A well-lit workplace is helpful; from the sofa that will not go.

The quality of paper I compared photos of these negatives with the scans shown on the screen. The same result as in Dias.

Paper photos:
Enter "Photo", lid lift, load paper photo on glass tables, press scan button, ready (principle works conditionally MagicTouch not here). Unfortunately, even here a quality problem: created at an A4 scanner scans of the same templates were mostly better quality.

120 Movies:
There are 2 mounts in which are placed like a paper photo on the glass table, and in whose cutouts the 60x45 or 60x60 Negative / Positive fit. Strips of negatives to be apparently cut into individual pictures! Unlike paper Photos (mounted in the cover) is scanned as with the slides via transmitted light. This limits the film size to the size of the transparency unit, so I therefore unfortunately can not scan my old Rollfilmschätzchen (60x90mm).

Given the time and effort that I would have to spend for scanning in spite of this "quick" device, the quality is just too bad. And to get it ready to hold for an occasional scan old photos, it is too expensive and too bulky. I gave it back.

Beautiful and functional 1 Rank: 5/5
May 19
only one floor Rank: 4/5
November 21
Ps3 eagle eye Rank: 4/5
December 18
Not bad but 46 Rank: 3/5
November 17

Related Reviews


Scan quality is good, bad workmanship.Epson Perfection V330 Scanner (4800dpi, USB, photo scanners, Scan to PDF) (Personal Computers) Good print and scan quality with big problems in wireless printingEpson Expression Home XP-312 multifunction printer (copier, scanner, printer, WLAN, USB 2.0) (Personal Computers) Immaculate Scanner - Fast & Good scan qualityHP Scanjet G4010 Flatbed Photo Scanner (4800 x 9600 dpi, USB, built-in transparency unit) L1956A (Accessories) good scan quality, ease of useEpson Perfection V370 Photo flatbed scanner USB port Black (Personal Computers) Playback quality is insufficientUSB SD AUX MP3 Adapter for Mazda 323 (MPV) from 10/02, 626, Demio from 01/00, from 10/01 Premacy, BK 3 to 12/08, 5 to 06/08, 6 GG / GY / GH up 03/10, RX8 (firmware from 9:55 except 9.81, 1.10), MX-5 NB / NC from 01 to 10/08 (electronic) very good scan quality, nevertheless trouble !!!Epson Perfection V600 Photo Scanner Epson Scan 3.8 Epson Event Manager Epson Copy Utility Adobe Photoshop black / silver (Personal Computers) Hardware quality is insufficient, especially for the priceSynology DiskStation DS213J NAS servers (2-Bay, 1.2GHz, 512MB DDR3, 1x LAN, 2x USB 2.0) (Accessories) Picture quality is insufficient, but for this price ...Canon PowerShot A2500 Digital Camera (16 Megapixel, 5x opt. Zoom, 6.9 cm (2.7 inch) display, image stabilized) (Electronics) Product quality is insufficientYahee365 laptop table bed table notebook reading table made of bamboo 50cm x 30cm (C) Voice quality is insufficientJabra Speak 510 for PC Bluetooth speakerphone for PC, Tablet, Smartphone optimized (Mobile conferencing solution, USB, Bluetooth 3.0) (Electronics) Good scan qualityPlustek 7600i SE Opti film scanner (electronic) Quality processed insufficient, wrongAdento SmartCase iPad Air Cover in green - Smart Cover Case with back protection for the iPad Air (Electronics) Quality judgment insufficient! 1x used and already broken!Ösenzange Pliers for eyelets punch heavy version (Misc.) Quality is insufficientFitness Josera dog food (Misc.) too expensive, quality is insufficientSystafex Carbon Auto cushion for cars 12V with switch (Automotive) Color design is not thought out, quality is insufficientrooCASE Apple iPad Air Ultra Slim Case Cover - Horizontal Vertical Stand Smart Cover function Supports Sleep / Wake function (scharwz - Origami) (Electronics) hmm ... the mobile phone is top but because the quality was insufficient drittanbierterLG KU990 Viewty mobile phone (UMTS, HSDPA, 5 megapixel) (Electronics) Quality and insufficient protective effect!15 / 15.6 / 16/17 / 17.3 / 18 / 18.4 / 19 "inch notebook laptop bag CASE (18-19" Inside dimensions: (L x W x H) 47 x 32 x 5 cm) Image quality is insufficientWINGONEER Video S-Video to VGA Converter AV Adapter for Monitor Camera Converter Converter (Electronics)