So just before the perfect game

I am by gamers and are the first Atari. Wolfenstein I've played in the original / first version, even the comic online multiplayer game, hence the title I also know.

I want to keep it, not so long, because the game has the essential characteristics are the entscheident:

Pro:
+ The violence is well represented, although cut, but it's really brutal.
+ The atmosphere and story are cinema Reif. The voice acting is good, the soundtrack is good.
+ Old Wolfenstein feeling is there, you have to pick up objects, not just run over it. Same items as helmets etc. are considered armor.
+ Spoiler ... comes right ... sure you read the want? Let it rather ... You can play the first level of the original Wolfenstein.

Neutral:
+ -The Graphics are really only 'goes like this'. Paying attention to the worn weapon, this is very nice to look at, is directed to his view of the world you think of XBox 360 Nivaeu.

Negatives:
-Waffenanimation. The first shot of my Thompson modeled sounds like a sack of shells. Blank cartridges.
-Hitboxen. Once taken from the blank cartridge, the opponent bends slightly, then is quickly. The even better GTA4 solved.
-Hitboxen The second: knife thrown into the foot = dead.
-Waffen- And weapon selection. The weapon selection is low. All weapons of the powerful Germans and the Allies, are futuristic. How So?
Robots. Please people, I understand the combination of exoskeleton and human, the fusion of man and machine, but a complete robot with independent - perfect - AI? In 1945? : D Unfortunately, too much.

Conclusion: A good story, well told, many Wow and shock moments, funny ideas. But the implementation of the arms breaks the game's neck. A wild Geballer without major alternations. One can say: Hey, it is now times a shooter. But the best example of a better, the Metro-series for me. I believe because I could play 2000 level and would still excited. Thus, only 4 star scarce. One star deduction for weapons and exaggerated super robot. Too Bad.