The best Swan Gesamtaufnahme

The best Swan Gesamtaufnahme

Tchaikovsky - Swan Lake (Swan Lake) / The Philadelphia Orchestra, Sawallisch (Audio CD)

Customer Review

Generally I go to look for the best recording of a work and here I present the result:

Selection:
In Swan Lake Sawallisch, Previn, Gergiev and Ozawa were available.

Gergiev and Previn also provide a good recording, however Previn can in many places come to the fore and the brass-destructs as an epochal oeuvre.
Gergiev believes only in fast-looking titles, such as at the scene no. 1, it succeeds but in adagio stressed pieces not to produce a kind of elegant severity (eg the main theme.)
Ozawa has completely failed the admission in my opinion, he destroyed the work by means of mechanical play. He lacks sämtliches sense of Tchaikosvsky and especially the breathtaking main theme is heruntergehetzt. The recording of the Brandenburger I would like to call at this point but as a secret, something is missing to Sawallisch, but this recording is the level significantly above the current recordings.

Sawallisch's work:

Sawallisch and the Philharmonia Orchestra convince other hand completely. Already the introduction or its shallowness has enchanted me. Then he is able to create a positive, intoxicating mood in Scene 1. The same applies to the title "Danse des coupes". When Waltz in A flat major a fantastic performance, a put themselves in the concert hall is offered to the listener immediately succeeds.
When Danse des Cygnes V harp performance can only be described as brilliant.
The Mazurka, Spanish Dance and the finals are to be regarded as further highlights of the work.
The main theme, however, is not of this world, I like the whole work best anyway, but the way the orchestra lead by Sawallisch sets a new benchmark.

Criticism of other reviewers I can only describe as unfounded. Especially in the non-rigid adherence to the pace is the magic of the main theme. Certainly, it is unlike other recordings rather slow, but in my view it must be exactly at this rate are played, a tempo increase would destroy the spirit of the work, which Ozawa well demonstrated. Only Karajan's main theme I like a touch better of him, however, there's no complete recording.

Conclusion:
To me, that is the reference image in terms of perfect implementation of Tchaikovsky's presentation in conjunction with excellent sound and well-considered self-interpretations. The latter are also absolutely necessary for a demarcation from the crowd.
Especially newer interpretations fall into mechanical play manner and to rapidly chosen tempos.
Sawallisch succeeds, however, to capture the magic of the work exemplary.

The price is 12 euros for a complete recording in the acceptable range.
Therefore strong buy recommendation

Small but nice! 69 Rank: 4/5
October 8
A life supermarchée Rank: 5/5
May 17
Magnificent brushes Rank: 5/5
November 22
As a pen Rank: 3/5
August 20
Siphon brand ICO in Chantilly Rank: 5/5
March 13
Very mini Rank: 5/5
September 16

Related Reviews


Certainly the bestPractical English Usage (Paperback) Clearly the best at the time in the compact segment!Sony Cyber-shot DSC-P200 Digital Camera Black (7 Megapixel) (Electronics) One of the best compact cameras with good price-performance ratioFujifilm FinePix F200EXR Digital Camera (12MP, 5x opt. Zoom, 3 '' display, image stabilizer) Silver (Electronics) Currently the best Nikon for semi-professionals and amateurs!Nikon D750 SLR Digital Camera (24.3 megapixels, 8.1 cm (3.2 inch) display, HDMI, USB 2.0) Kit incl. 24-85mm Lens (Electronics) One of the best covers I've ever ownedMANNA Ultraslim Sony Xperia Z3 Case | bag nubuck leather, brown |, openable Case | Cover with Micro Fleece - upholstery | Cover for Sony Z3 with 5.2 '' screen (electronics) The Revolution - The best elec. ToothbrushPhilips Sonicare HX9332 / 04 DiamondClean sonic toothbrush, ceramic white (Personal Care) The best messenger on the marketThreema (App) the best gameConstruction Simulator 2014 (App) In my opinion the best of the Fast and Furious soundtrackFast and Furious 5 Rio Heist-(Audio CD) ... The best folk album in 2009Sigh No More (Audio CD) This song is not "The Best Side of Life"The Best Side of Life (Audio CD) "Real Love" ... the best album she has ever brought out!Real Love (Ltd.Deluxe Edt.) (Audio CD) The best record for a long time ...Uprising in Cockaigne (Audio CD) The best player I've ever had !!!!!!!!!!!!Philips DVP 5980/12 DVD player (DivX Certified, USB port, 1080p upscaling, HDMI) black (Electronics) TV Spielfilm is the best app of its kindTV MOVIE - TV program (app) Wow wow wow - one of the best smartphones on the market (as of 01/2014)BlackBerry Z10 Smartphone (4.2-inch display, touch screen, 8 megapixel camera, 16GB expandable memory, 4G LTE) (Electronics) one of the best libraries AppsBR library (App) Really the best bowling game!PBA® Bowling Challenge (App) Buy it !!! The best supplement for beginners.Canon EF 50mm 1: 1.8 II lens (52mm filter thread) (Camera)