I own the Xbox One now about half a year, games especially first person shooters and sports games, and can therefore give a reasoned opinion on this controller. Before the Xbox One I've played on the Xbox 360 and very often with friends on your PS3 or PS2, so I have enough to compare it ... The controller sits perfectly in the hand and has hardly any weaknesses in my opinion. Especially for ego shooter like Battlefield 4 or Call of Duty, this controller is perfect. At first I found the controller of the X360 a little better, because the sticks are larger and more cumbersome, thereby aiming in shooters falls initially easier ... After a period of acclimatization but you get used to the sticks and then the controller is just perfect for each types of games The Xbox One controller has, incredibly, the 360 controller even topped that I have not thought possible and therefore gets 5 stars