Theoretically, good, practical Poor

Theoretically, good, practical Poor

Philips BDP3100 / 12 Blu Ray Player (HDMI, 1080p upscaler, DivX Certified, USB 2.0) (Electronics)

Customer Review

A little over a year I had decided at last to jump on the HD train, and zuzulegen a Blu-ray player. After some discussion, I seemed to have a good and reasonable 3100/12 Blu-ray player with the Philips BDP found. After a firmware update was nachgeschoben after playback problems with the Avatar Extended Special Edition prompt which quickly corrected the problems. "Good service", I thought. Unfortunately, I did not know then that a few months later following firmware update (May 2011) would be the last of its kind.

Although the player does a good job most of the time, it came as it had come. In summer 2011, appeared with Battle: Los Angeles, the first Blu-ray movie, whose acceptance of the players refused with the lapidary words "Unknown Disc". On three other players from other manufacturers, this Blu-ray, however, ran without any problems, so it was at the Philips device.

Then I contacted the Philips Service and informed these about the problem, and apparently a firmware was necessary to ensure the playback of newer titles. Unfortunately, this is a typical problem of the Blu-ray standard and the manufacturers have really to publish committed has regularly updates altered copy protection mechanisms. Anyway you look thanked for pointing out and assured me that they would take care of it. After a month without a reply I asked again after and was told that no one knew how long the software department would need, but one would come forward.

That was the end of July 2011. Meanwhile, we have the end of March 2012, and of course has since done nothing. No further response from the Philips customer service and of course no other firmware update, though now more films have been added that do not or will not play faulty while they work on the players from other manufacturers without problems. Here, the previously problematic films at a glance:

- Battle: Los Angeles = will not play ("Unknown Disc")
- The Runaways = will not play ("Unknown Disc")
- The Thing (2011) = does not play ("Unknown Disc")
- Green Hornet = playback problems and dropouts in the last 20 minutes
- Conan (2011) = playback problems and dropouts in the last 20 minutes
- Transformers 3 = sporadic image stuttering and audio dropouts in HD sound
- Super 8 = sound skips HD sound

and other movies would surely follow if I did not replace the player soon against a Samsung player.

After this experience, I can now and in the future only strongly advise against the purchase of a Philips Blu-ray player. Since the Blu-ray standard, due to the frequent changes adopted in the copy protection requires regular firmware updates, you should opt only for producers who also comply with this obligation and update not let their customers out in the cold. From my perspective, Philips does not belong uniquely to this group of producers.

Well ... 96 Rank: 2/5
March 23
5 stars in every respect Rank: 5/5
March 12
Lexar Card Reader 24 in 1 Rank: 5/5
November 20
i like motor storm Rank: 5/5
October 8
Perfect January 1667 Rank: 5/5
September 29
Do nothing at all Rank: 1/5
May 21

Related Reviews


More theoretical than practicalThe Genius of intuition (Paperback) Good idea, poor workmanshipWolfcraft dowel in the storage case, 4645000 (tool) Good practice / PriceONX3 Samsung Galaxy Core Plus G3500 Sport Fitness Jogging Adjustable Arm Band Case & 3.5mm In Ear Earbud headphones base (black) (Others) Good practice that any developer needs to knowThe Pragmatic Programmer: From Journeyman to Master (Paperback) Teaching is both theoretical and practical meditation type "mindfulness"Meditate every day: 25 lessons for live mindfully (+ 1CD mp3 included) (Paperback) good practice guide 2Stretching and strength training - Health - Beauty - Physical preparation - 250 years (Paperback) Good design, poor qualityTorras "Forest" Ultra-Slim Flip Leather Case Protective Skin Cover Case for Sony Xperia Z2 with business card holder - black (Electronics) Good, practical, lowJJC NS-J1 - Quick Strap camera strap (shoulder strap, shoulder strap, strap) for gentle comfort - ergonomic design - for example for Canon EOS 10D, 20D, 30D, 40D, 50D, 60D, 300D, 350D, 400D, 450D, 500D, 550D, 600D, 650D, 1000D, 1100D (Electronics) invites good, but poor workmanshipMusicMan USB charger / AC adapter / power adapter 230V Black - Original Accessories MusicMan (Electronics) Good equipment, poor software CDPlustek SmartOffice PS286 Plus duplex document scanner (accessory) Good product - poor Product description: Does not fit BB9790!Original Blumax ® Leather Case Dark Brown for Blackberry (RIM) Bold 9790 with retreat function, cell phone pocket, Case, Case, Case, Slide, screen protectors, Secure (Electronics) Quality is good, practicalGoodstyle leather bag "Talis" Book Type Case for Sony Xperia Z1 made of genuine leather with pocket for credit or business cards, Black (Wireless Phone Accessory) Theoretically good game, practically unfinished game and frustration purBattlefield 4 - Day One Edition (including China Rising expansion pack.) - [PlayStation 4] (Video Game) Range: Very good, quality: Very good, Practical application: Good to very good, Price: Very good.Heytec Heyco 50834000000 Feinmechaniker bit set (tool) Good approach, poor implementation - there are better choicesThinkTank Hydrophobia 70-200 (Camera) NHL 13: Plenty of good ideas, poorly executed.NHL 13 Stanley Cup Collector's Edition (Exclusive to Amazon.de) (Video Game) Good approach poor implementationBrita water filter XXL Optimax Cool 8.5 liters, white (household goods) Good machine poor service also from AmazonEaster Prima Latte espresso machine with milk frother, 15 bar (household goods) Good concept poorly executedJumbl high-resolution 22 MP All-In-1 scanner / digitizer - Converts 35 mm negatives, 35mm slides, 110, 126, 127 and Super 8 movies on 22-Megapixel Digital JPEGs - No computer / no software required to operate the device - Features 2.4-inch color LCD and TV output - Includes quick-load adapter for quick, repeatedly scanning slides and negatives (Office supplies & stationery)