Two significant drawbacks

Two significant drawbacks

Mad Catz FLY5 Flight Stick PC (personal computer)

Customer Review

First thing first: it's my first joystick. I need one because I want to stay in a little workout as a real pilot in simulation with MS FS9 on a particular type of aircraft (Embraer Legacy 600) because I real only very rarely fly him due to the crisis. So for me, among other things, the realistic control is paramount.

The choice fell on this stick because it is relatively inexpensive, two throttles and has many buttons, on which you can do many things themselves, which would otherwise be the pilot non-flying do. What a small drawback is the same mentioned: the thrust levers are left and you control with the right; thus one is set to the first officer position. Positive: In particular, the 2 buttons on the left of the thumb are somewhat since, would be where many real aircraft the elevator trim button. The two buttons to the right of the thumb I use for flaps down, very practical. Before the thrust levers, there are also two buttons, which are ideal for activating the go-around mode and the autopilot - with me it is my 2004 did not succeed in the latter despite programming software and the settings in FS, the button corresponding to occupy.

The stick is manifold set, the tilt of the stick, the length of the handle, the inclination and the distance thumb buttons are adjustable. Unfortunately, the height of the sticks on the base plate can not be changed; me it is way too high mounted. Processing affects not particularly high quality; but positive are the silky smooth running and precise thrust levers to mention.

Clearly negative:

* The stand is indeed very wide and laterally towards the player also deep. One can therefore side neat row and also attract back (see picture) - but when you press forward tilts the part, because since the base plate is too short. Absolutely incomprehensible, as a construction.

* The forces on deflection of the stick from the middle position are totally unrealistic. A so strongly defined central position there is not the real aircraft. Although counteracting forces leading to a central position when the two forces are equal. But it snaps nothing, and when it is deflected from this position to increase the powers of zero to a certain degree to kontiniuierlich. This stick (and probably most others) is the exact opposite: it takes a lot of strength to move the stick in the center position; but if the middle layer is only once overcome, the control forces are low. This is very inconvenient if you want to do a hand-flown instrument approach, in which one draws with tiny movements from the center position. Even when taxiing on the ground that's annoying. Just totally unrealistic and mechanically easy to fix (just two adjustable springs per axle). And is called the part "flight stick". Too Bad.

very happy 110 Rank: 4/5
May 29
the last China scrap Rank: 1/5
June 25
Until the end Rank: 5/5
October 10

Related Reviews


Two major drawbacksGoodstyle UltraSlim Case V2, bag with stand and presentation function for Samsung Galaxy Note II, black small, inexpensive and without significant drawbacksSmart MX04 HDCA HDTV satellite receiver (HDMI, USB PVR-ready, Conax card reader, smart EPG by TV Today) (Electronics) Super Bag with only two small drawbacks!Samsung Galaxy S3 i9300 Cell Phone Leather Case Cover, QUBITS Retailverpackung (White) (Electronics) A great thing, but with two significant weaknessesParrot Flower Power Wireless plant sensor Bluetooth Green (Electronics) Top unit with two small drawbacksHuawei MediaPad X1 7.0 tablet PC (17.8 cm (7 inch) display, 1.6GHz quad-core processor, 2GB RAM, 16GB HDD, LTE, Android 4.2) (Personal Computers) Top-feel, but two significant weaknesses ...Devil BT Bamster portable Bluetooth Soundbar Black (Electronics) Good player - operation albeit with significant drawbacksArchos 3.2 multimedia player 8GB 8.12 cm (3.2 inch) touchscreen display, Android 2.2 Froyo, WiFi, Flash Support, 360 ° position sensor, USB 2.0) (Electronics) Well-made product with significant deficiencies in the handlingPhilips LivingColors Micro, energy-saving LED technology, 64 colors, control on the product, white 7001831PH (household goods) From Ipad for androidSony Xperia SGP611 Z3 Compact Tablet 20.3 cm (8 inch) WUXGA Triluminos display, 2.5GHz quad-core, 3GB of RAM, 8.1 megapixel camera, Android 4.4, 16GB of internal memory) black (Personal Computers) Photographing as before, only more comfortable and better!Sony DSC-RX10 Digital Camera (20.2 megapixels, 7.6 cm (3 inch) display, BIONZ X, 1.4 megapixel OLED viewfinder, NFC) (Electronics) good Blu-ray player with good playback of Blu-ray, but a few good app functionsLG BP420 3D Blu-ray player (Smart TV, DLNA, HDMI, 1080p upscaler, LAN, USB) (Electronics) Party pooper on the road!TP-Link TL-MR3040 3G / 4G wireless router (2.4GHz, 150Mbit / s, USB 2.0, Travel Router (AP), WISP Client Router) (Personal Computers) Good Cover with a few small flawsBelkin Essential 031 Protective Cover for iPhone 4 / 4S (TPU) black / gray (Accessories) Super 1880 3737Smoby - 521,591 - Twin Stroller For Doll - Bébé Confort (Toy) Very good sports sleeve with problems in Sony Xperia Z.iGadgitz Black Reflective Anti-Slip Neoprene Sports Armband arm bag protection Skin Case for Sony Xperia Z Android Smartphone (Personal Computers) Without balance, he would be a stunner!Rowenta VU5540 Standventilator Turbo Silence (tool) LG Homebot 3.0 vs Neato Signature Pro vs. Navibot VR10F71 vs Roomba 780 *** Comparing January 2014LG Hom-Bot robot vacuum cleaner VR6270LVMB (Dual Eye 2.0, dust container, Smart Turbo mode) anthracite (household goods) Canon EF 100mm 1: 2.8 Macro USM and Canon EF 100mm 2.8L IS USM Macro?Canon EF 100mm / 1: 2.8 Macro USM lens (58mm filter thread) (Accessories) Festool CXS Li 1,5 SetFestool cordless drill CXS 564271 Li 1, 5 Set (tool)