Undoubtedly a masterpiece - with weaknesses

Undoubtedly a masterpiece - with weaknesses

The Wall (Audio CD)

Customer Review

"The Wall" is unquestionably a monster of an album. With more than 30 million units, it is today the world's best-selling double album. And it is the one album that changed the classic Pink Floyd sound drastically. Sprawling Instrumental deposits were passé, the concept album served as a mouthpiece for Roger Waters, the first priority put the testimony in the music - the result had undoubtedly sound very different. Therefore, it is difficult to assess "The Wall" in direct comparison with its predecessors.

But the story of the deep look at the broken soul of the protagonist 'Pink', implemented in this musical form, is truly an artistic masterpiece. One has to deal with the complexity of the work already to grasp the cynical lyrics or the planned down to the smallest detail sound effects. On top of that the work is Floyd-typical course perfectly recorded and mixed with remarkable vitality, so that everyone listening test is a real acoustic experience.

Still, perfect score gets "The Wall" in spite of these laurels of me not. Because every now and then choked the story under the bombast, the Roger Waters ascends. This is particularly evident is in "Waiting for the Worms" or "The Trial" at the end of the work where the music has hardly anything to do with rock, but rather - drifts towards Musical - just hard to bear for me. Also known everyone "Another Brick in the Wall (Part II)" is a completely atypical Floyd Sound, with it, although the band managed even to the disco dance floors, many fans but leaving a little perplexed.

Fortunately, at that time very dominant Waters but still left a little in his work to meddle, and so David Gilmour came about, with his melodic sense to intersperse a few highlights, most notably of course the overriding "Comfortably Numb". Here was particularly clear that Waters and Gilmour is supplemented musically perfect, and that it is a pity that after "The Wall" was over with this fruitful collaboration. Furthermore, I think "Hey You", "Mother", the double track "Empty Spaces" / "Young Lust", "One of my Turns" and especially "Nobody Home" for outstanding songs that work outside of the concept even on its own ,

The bottom line is "The Wall" a tough nut that must be cracked - and for that you need time, understanding of the texts and optimally an outstanding headset. Those who appreciate Pink Floyd more for early works or just "Another Brick ..." knows from the radio, will probably be less happy with "The Wall".

no good radio reception Rank: 1/5
June 22
Sublime result! Rank: 4/5
February 24
Take Me To Church by Hosier Rank: 5/5
November 28
reliable test 1 Rank: 5/5
March 10

Related Reviews


Price / performance ratio okay, but with weaknessesMicrosoft Wireless Desktop 3000 Keyboard and Mouse Cordless black (German keyboard layout, QWERTY) (Personal Computers) Very good smartphone with weaknesses in the performanceLG G3 Smartphone (14 cm (5.5 inches) Quad HD IPS display, 2.5 GHz quad-core processor, 13-megapixel camera, 16GB memory, Android 4.4) - Titan Black (Wireless Phone) Good idea, but with weaknessesDream Farm Revolutionary infuser Teafu, firetruck red (household goods) Very well thought out support, ease of installation, but with weaknesses in production.Cabstone Easyfix Ultra Slim XL (51951) (Black / Silver) (Accessories) Good Soundbar with weaknessesHarman Kardon SB 35 Sabre speaker system in the ultraslim design silver with active wireless subwoofer (Electronics) good mouse with weaknessesFightMouse Pro - Mouse - laser - 9 button (s) - wired - USB (Personal Computers) Good keyboard but also with weaknessesAnker® Slim Folio Bluetooth Keyboard Case Keyboard Case for iPad Air iPad 5 - PU Leather Case and removable German keyboard with magnetic holder (Tuxedo Black) Good workmanship with weaknesses in the softwareAsus DSL AC68U AC1900 Black Diamond Dual Band Wireless Modem Router (VDSL2 / ADSL2 / 2 +, 802.11 a / b / g / n / ac, Annex ABJ, Gigabit LAN, 1x USB 3.0, Print FTP UPnP server, IPv6, 8x SSID) (Accessories) Satisfactory with weaknessesBosch PTS 10 table circular saw Home Series (1,400 W, saw nominal Ø 254 mm) (Tools) good price with weaknesses1/4 guitar with book and Karaoke CD Good phone with weaknessesNokia Lumia 925 Smartphone (11.4 cm (4.5 inch) WXGA HD OLED touch screen, 8.7 megapixel camera, 1.5 GHz dual core processor) white (Wireless Phone) The original with weaknessesThe Phantom of the Opera (Audio CD) Hapthisch quality and well thought-out toasters, but with weaknesses imm DetailRussell Hobbs 21391-56 Colours Flame Red long slot toaster, 6 adjustable browning levels, bun warmer (household goods) Good picture and sound quality, but with weaknesses in 3D and the operationPhilips 46PFL5507K / 12 117 cm (46 inches) 3D LED-backlit TV (Full HD, 400Hz PMR, DVB-C / T / S, CI +, Smart TV Plus, WiFi, USB Recording) silver black brushed (Electronics) Good product, albeit with weaknessesHauck travel cot Dream n Play Plus (Baby Product) Priced entry-level model with weaknesses, but top price / performance ratioSeverin MW 7848 microwave with grill and convection function, stainless steel brushed / 900 watts / 1400 watts grill / oven 25 L (Misc.) .... With weaknesses, unfortunately brokenWithings Pulse Ox Activity and Health Tracker (equipment) Auvisio: masterpiece with little flaws.auvisio Mini MP3 Station "MPS 550.cube" with integrated Radio (Electronics) Beautiful cats living area with weaknessesNanook Kratzbaum Sigurd 1 - extremely thick scratch trunks 11 cm Ø, 38 kg maximum shelf stable - adjustable up to 275 cm height, beige brown - with cave cubicles, game cable, tunnel, pawn (Misc.)