Unreliable and therefore unusable

Unreliable and therefore unusable

WD My Personal Cloud Cloud Storage 3TB ((8.9 cm (3.5 inches), USB 3.0, NAS) white (Personal Computers)

Customer Review

*************
***
*** Update 25/01/2015: downgraded to 1 star. Justification see at the end of the review.
***
*************

I own a lot of WD hard drives - they were so far always very reliable, and the price / performance ratio has also always fit. With the brand WD I am very happy - but this product has very disappointed me, see in the following text the reasons to do so.

Two reasons have prompted me to buy the My Cloud (in the 3TB version):
- Central storage in the whole house
- Access from iTunes possible

Unfortunately, the reasons for the deductions are completely unnecessary in small, but extremely annoying details or misunderstood in function descriptions:

1.)
The hard drive is running (as already written several times here) continuously without shutting down after a while of inactivity. I have as a first action after the purchase (early April 2014) updated directly to the latest firmware, but to no avail. This means that I have the hard disk automatically when not in use manually power down (= plug), I do not really want to, because the hard drive is well hidden in a corner in a small room. That alone is at least 1 point deduction with the cautious hope that at some point an appropriate firmware appears.

Much more important, and even a __richtige Enttäuschung__ was here:

2.)
My iPad can __nicht__ access the music stored on the My Cloud via iTunes !!! After a few trials and research on the net my fear was confirmed: It's impossible! (If you like, will take place this well-made English Review a second opinion: [...]).

Because that was really my main reason for buying, my least 2 points deduction is worth. The disk loses for me the most value. The reason is probably that the iOS (iPad, iPhone) to another protocol for the transmission of data required as a "normal" Mac or PC.

This also means that the inclusion of music in the "normal" iTunes on Mac and PC of course is possible. These deal with the My Cloud as a normal network drive, and the access is possible without any problems.

And here is a point of criticism with regard to the marketing of these hard disk: WD implying (original quote from the WD website) "supports iTunes" and hereinafter also the Installation Guide "to access iTunes on your personal cloud" that for all systems is of course possible, iTunes support. In addition, we read again and again the word "iTunes Server", which also suggests a complete support.

Think again! (What I know now)

Can accuse you WD nothing: There is nowhere explicitly something along the lines of "you can use the stored songs from your My Cloud as iTunes playlist on your iPad play." So we must accuse myself, I did not read the description properly .. ,

I would, however, have wished that WD had written something in the nature, at least as a note / footnote: "Note: A direct involvement in the form of a playlist in iTunes is currently not possible to on iPad and iPhone."

Maybe I would have bought the hard drive anyway, and just one point deduction given (wg. Continuous operation).

*************
***
*** Update 25/01/2015: downgraded to 1 star. Justification.
***
*************

I really tried everything and had patience of a saint, but now this is the end:
- The firmware is up to date
- Access of the same devices / locations on the WLAN or the router to which the hard drive is connected via cable, works perfectly (Internet, Watch Ever, iTunes Store, ...)
- See also the comments below the review for the classification of discontent

The hard drive is still unable, without errors and disconnections 5 GB (or less) to be transferred in one go. In the moment in which I write this, even the simple deletion of files 10 ("Make sure that you are connected to the network is ..." failed because the connection is again interrupted. This is the hard disk de facto unusable in its role as wireless hard drive. as an automatic backup solution to remain silent on the use of all.

I'm going to shut down the hard drive. Maybe I'll buy an external 3.5 "hard drive enclosure and installing the WD there, then the purchase was at least not totally unnecessary.

I'm sorry that it has come to - I was really patient and have often turned a blind eye two all.

Perfect Keyboard Rank: 5/5
November 19
A wonder for cheap Rank: 5/5
April 16
BUT very nice product! 1 Rank: 2/5
August 29
29 Adapter Rank: 4/5
June 25
Sony HDR-PJ780VE Rank: 4/5
February 22
Beautiful TV 1 1 Rank: 5/5
August 5

Related Reviews


too unreliable and therefore unusableEye-Fi Eye-Fi 8GB MOBI Mobi 8GB Memory Card (Personal Computers) Unfortunately defective and therefore unusablePhilips SB7300 / 12 Shoqbox Portable Premium Bluetooth speakers with integrated microphone and touch sensor (Personal Computers) Supports HDMI 1.4a and therefore CEC, ARC, 3D, 4K2K, and Ethernet over HDMI. Robust plug connection.deleyCON HDMI to Mini HDMI Adapter - HDMI Female to Mini HDMI Male [plated contacts] (Electronics) Regarded as "spare parts" and therefore can not be registered with PhilipsPhilips Sonicare Diamond Clean handpiece incl. 1 spare brush + Probepackung St. Sin No. 1 Verarsche and rip off and therefore not recommendedHD + Card 12 Months HD + programs (Personal Computers) The new version comes very officially and therefore groovy!That what one most wants [feat. Petra Manuela] (MP3 Download) A serious hardware. Too bad it does not exist in lower power and therefore less heavyTransformer 110 220 V 40/80 WATTS UP (Miscellaneous) Great for anti pilling and therefore less dust ...Fleece blanket Isba - Myosotis (220x240 cm) Poor quality and almost unusable ProductLOUPE Watchmaker Watch Repair 20X Light On Mount Glasses Free Main (Electronics) Well thought out, but without practical value and therefore uselessSony Ericssion LiveView Bluetooth external display (for Android OS mobile phones, other manufacturers, for mobile phones) Black (Wireless Phone Accessory) Unlike the other and therefore an absolute highlight.Dead Can Dance (Audio CD) good price - only works half, therefore unusableAdapter for car and trailer 13 pole to 7 pole (adapter / trailer coupling of 13-pin car on 7-pin trailer), iapyx® is just as I thought - works or fits or sitting or tastes, and therefore - we'll be back!Everlast Training Glove Leather Boxing Gloves "Fighter" (Sports Apparel) 08/15 goods identical to other Noname and wider than necessary and therefore unsuitabledeleyCON HDMI to Mini HDMI Adapter - HDMI Female to Mini HDMI Male [plated contacts] (Electronics) Very good product and therefore very good service !!!Toshiba Flash Air Memory Card / wireless-enabled memory card (16GB, Class 10, Wi-Fi SD card) (Personal Computers) quality fits. Practical and therefore is now always thereJJC cleaning Lenspen / Cleaning Pen + Blower / Puster (Black) + microfiber cleaning cloth (optional) Works quickly and therefore goodLexar 32GB microSDHC CL10 Memory Card incl. MicroSDHC USB adapter (accessory) nice and soft, keep warm, but hardly stretchable and therefore very narrow and difficult to pull on the baby legsHoppediz Baby tulips cashmere / merino wool Norwegians - Design Grey (Textiles) Great sound (which has to be adjusted with difficulty), but unfortunately too bulky and therefore inconvenientTritton PRO + 5.1 Surround Headset for PS4 / PS3, Xbox 360, PC / Mac - White (Personal Computers)