I so enjoyed the first two opus that I was looking forward to reading this new slice of life Penderwick sisters. I just finished it: what a disappointment. History does not tell me frankly passionate and I am very disappointed of the language used ("closes", "beat up"), this is due to the translation? I do not know but I had the memory of well-bred young girls and not at all silly as I felt. In short, this one should be avoided ....