A Capella good Instrumented deficient

First, the Wise Guys Album (A Capella):
The (now no longer so, the individual versions there was already a couple of weeks) new board of Wise Guys moves at the top of the expected, if one may so express it.
There are some very nice pieces here: humorous take the Wise Guys, the "German Railways" and the German pseudo ghetto rapper scene ("Hurth") on's grain, but have "not planned that was" as with well nachdenklicheres in program.
Really negative from the series strikes the a capella CD for me nothing, I can the CD from beginning to end without listening to in between constantly have to skip tracks.

What for me but clearly negative, the instrumented version (CD 2):
I hope this CD is not created at the initiative of the Wise Guys, but the producers because it devalues ​​the otherwise beautiful Wise Guys songs very extreme. The pop a capella music, the Wise Guys distinguished and so successfully made, degenerates in the instrumented version unfortunately any Dudel Pop. Nothing distinguishes these pieces, nothing lifts from other radio-pabulum from (even the intonation of the singer seems to me in some pieces clearly ... listless? As in the a capella version). But I like the Wise Guys, because they stand out from the interchangeability of the other constant background noise, so far this pop versions are counterproductive for me. I hope the Wise Guys use their time in the future more meaningful - like with friends and family, but please do not for pop arrangements.

Overall, there's me for the a capella CD five stars (expectations well met), one for the instrumented. Since me the double CD but only cost four euros more than the pure a capella album, I summed up a total of four stars.