At most good ideas

At most good ideas

Panic (Audio CD)

Customer Review

To say the same: I had this disc as underground secret borrowed from a mate, I would rate more generous; would this music a side project by Trent Reznor, he designed out of boredom between two other projects, and has made available as a free download on the net, I would not say anything - but I have become aware of this album by explicitly positive reviews, and have the full retail price! paid, and from this point of my enthusiasm remains very limited.

Album and band are touted with the promise of here would 20s swing and electric Mucke combined - both styles of music, I appreciate very much, and imagine a successful combination very attractive before. The emphasis here is on "successful" because what the band presented here is more than a little arable.
First of all, the actual swing percentage is by no means the dominant, trendsetting aspect of this music, but exhausted the very most from occasional swing elements that are woven into a rather simple electro-soundscape - for a quick one Barpiano as a brass-Keyboard. A real creative portion of the band is barely perceptible, instead one has time and again one has the impression of hearing created with little effort remixes.
For long stretches, the album offers at most swing way tinged synth arrangements that you could sell as easily next 0815-pop song in a different formation. "Maniac" is a perfectly ordinary (and very tiring) Electric number whose only Swing-share is a vocal that could identify a lot of imagination as a chanson-way. "The Dirty Side of the Street" - in my opinion still the best song of the album - is little more than a double of played Boosts BigBand song, and this is strongly reminiscent of the intro melody of the Muppet Show.
Anyone who wants to like this approach called minimalism, I daresay, the band wanted to just not make an effort: Especially in the second half if the already very sparse powder is fired, the album degenerates into a series of vierminütig then rattling Drumcomputer- loops, over which one has sporadically thrown a handful of faded 20's samples.

The narrow musical range could have been offset by a skillful vocal use again, but again, the band holds back - just two pieces have clear, undistorted vocals on, otherwise pervades the album over long distances tinny-unintelligible murmur, which is less listening when that one accepts it as a mere part of the commotion in the background.

I'm sure this album will also find his lover, I only regret that I can not be one of them, and just want to put this review each his heart, not to rush to judgment, but before purchasing one that is listed auditions lead to heart: Myself this disc has long stretches cold left not because I could not do anything with the two main musical ingredients, but because they were combined so listless in my opinion.
Already after the first hearing I did not feel the urge to listen to the album again, got it but then did anyway, and finally within these 54 minutes, the one or the other out part that will satisfy, or which can be described as generally original. But something that takes that leaves a listen up, I have not found. And the latest in the third run, it takes the sound carpet hardly notice.

Related Reviews


A good idea, but ...Ultranatura Barbecue charcoal smoker Alamo - Barbecue trolley (Garden) A good idea, but unreliability 1Jedi Globe E27 LED RGB + White 806 lm LED bulb with remote control suspension 10 x 10 x 19.8 cm (Housewares) A good idea 2The Financial Times Guide: 60 management models (Hardcover) Good ideas but incompleteStar Wars: Empire at War - Gold Edition (computer game) Good ideas to varyFour seasons and gluten free without milk (Paperback) Good ideas leaded by a lack of monitoring of serversHomefront (video game) Good idea but average qualitySafe bicycle for pvc Santafe Garden (Garden) Good idea, with angry DetailsBosch Uneo cordless hammer drill "Easy" + 2 + 4 drill bits + battery and charger + trunk (14.4 V, max. Drilling diameter concrete 10 mm, 1.1 kg) (tool) Good idea, but quite poor implementationSyntrox Germany Digital beer dispenser without CO² cartridges beer cooler with pump function (household goods) Plenty of good ideas poorly implementedThe Guild 2: Renaissance (computer game) Good idea2 years device protection with theft protection for digital cameras 250.00 to 499.99 EUR (Accessories) Good idea but .... 1Tavola Swiss 2790000038 capsule dispenser for Nespresso (household goods) NHL 13: Plenty of good ideas, poorly executed.NHL 13 Stanley Cup Collector's Edition (Exclusive to Amazon.de) (Video Game) Good idea but unwieldyUltra Sport 20kg Dumbbell Set with 6 weight plates (equipment) Always a good idea 1Amazon.de Box with a gift card (heart) (gift card) Always a good idea 2Amazon.de voucher for printing (Various Topics) (Ecard Gift Certificate) Good idea, not quite as well implementedLeuchtturm1917 343,780 reading journal, diary for literature lovers (Office supplies & stationery) Good idea 73 Years Warranty Extension for Office accessories devices to 99.99 EUR (Accessories) A very good idea, unfortunately, poorly implementedRavensburger 00500 - tiptoi®: The pin (Toys)