Best compromise between disinfection and compatibility

Best compromise between disinfection and compatibility

Opti-Free Replenish Cleaners for soft contact lenses, supply pack 2 x 300 ml, 1-pack (1 x 600 ml) (Health and Beauty)

Customer Review

I have a lot of tests concerned about and of course both these also tested the other, popular all-in-one solution from Alcon (Optifree Pure Moist) itself and have come to the conclusion that the Replenish care products for me is the most suitable.

In support of: the combined solutions must perform a balancing act - on the one hand they should be disinfected as well as possible, on the other hand be as gentle to the eye. After all tests present me Replenish deal with this dilemma best. While those care agents with particularly good results in the disinfection all defective (!) Imports reviews in analyzing the ingredients, Replenish could thus convince that the disinfection only slightly worse turned out, the compatibility for the eye but, depending on the test institute, still with good was judged to satisfactory. Foundation Ökotest example, has far too little let my mind the fact that the solutions with particularly high disinfecting power have cell-damaging effects because of their ingredients, incorporated into the final test result. This was justified in his own words so that after rinsing the contact lenses after storage in solution no cell-damaging effects more were detected. I think this is also due to a relevant conversation with my ophthalmologist, frankly for bullshit! First, this statement would mean that you have to use for rinsing another liquid (approximately sterile saline), or how exactly will you otherwise rinse the harmful ingredients of this solution with this same solution ?! This in turn leads the principle of an all-in-one solution complete absurdity. Then I may as well resort to a multi-component system with hydrogen peroxide to disinfect - which is in principle recommended by ophthalmologists, as the most effective, but unfortunately this is also very uncomfortable. Secondly, one could so first remove the ingredients only superficially, because the soft lenses act like a sponge and soak up the solution during storage. A complete rinsing would therefore take far too long to be practical.

Otherwise it was as far as I've seen so far (you forgive me, I should have overlooked it), has unfortunately never addressed the question of a comparison with the Pure Moist solution from the same manufacturer in the other reviews about the product. My result on this issue in my research is that the Pure Moist still could better ratings in the compatibility retract, but the disinfecting effects is consistently reported as inadequate. Therefore, I would absolutely prefer this solution Replenish, really bad to the eye is not of two, but there is with regard to the disinfecting effect yet so important - at least the test results - but a significant difference. In practice, though I bestowed both solutions excellent comfort, but the knowledge of good desinfinzierende effect is worth it to me the slightly higher price anyway. For my Glubscher only the best! And this I can tell you all only also recommended.

Bad story, but cool pictures Rank: 3/5
February 9
Useful but not pleasant Rank: 4/5
October 29
it is read! Rank: 5/5
April 19
Tutti va bene 1 Rank: 4/5
February 2
Very good choice 19 Rank: 4/5
August 31
propeller Rank: 5/5
April 14

Related Reviews


best compromise between protection and aestheticsHTC ONE X Rubberized HARDSKIN CASE IN BLACK, QUBITS Retailverpackung (Electronics) The best compromise between compact and ... and more ...Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ50 Digital Camera EC S (10 megapixel, 12x opt. Zoom, 5.1 cm (2 inch) display, Image Stabilizer) Silver (Electronics) Best compromise between protection and sizeAnyMode Diary 2 Flip Case for Samsung Galaxy Note N7100 Black (Accessories) The best compromise between size and image qualitySony DSC-RX100 II Cyber-shot digital camera (20 megapixels, 3.6x opt. Zoom, 7.6 cm (3 inch) display, Full HD, image stabilized, NFC, WiFi) (Electronics) Not just for weed - Best compromise between price, quality and sizeGloria pressure sprayer pressure sprayer Prima 3 liters with vision panels and brass nozzle or Langze, yellow (garden products) The ideal compromise between power and compactnessRAVPower 10400 mAh Portable Charger with technology iSmart Element RP-PB07 (emergency external battery, 3.5A Output, Dual USB ports) Black (Electronics) Very good workmanship, good compromise between weight and protectionABUS bicycle lock Catena 685/75, 75 cm (equipment) Good compromise between DSLR and compactPanasonic Lumix DMC-FZ38 EG-K Digital Camera (12MP, 18x opt. Zoom, 6.9 cm (2.7 inch) display, image stabilizer) (Electronics) A compromise between flexibility and image qualityOlympus TG-850 Digital Camera (16 Megapixel CMOS sensor, 5x opt. Zoom, folding 7.6cm (3 inch) LCD, Full HD, waterproof to 10m) with 21mm Wide Angle Lens (Electronics) excellent compromise between smartphone and laptop basicNokia Asha 302 Smartphone HSUPA / HSDPA / GPRS / EGPRS wireless 3.5 G White (Electronics) Good compromise between wet and dry shaversPhilips AT750 / 26 Wet & Dry shaver Aqua Touch (Rasierschaumprobe) (Health and Beauty) Good compromise between performance and priceSynology DiskStation DS213J NAS servers (2-Bay, 1.2GHz, 512MB DDR3, 1x LAN, 2x USB 2.0) (Accessories) Coming from the D700: Ingenious compromise between size and performance with small defectsNikon D750 SLR Digital Camera (24.3 megapixels, 8.1 cm (3.2 inch) display, HDMI, USB 2.0) Kit incl. 24-85mm Lens (Electronics) Coming from the D700: Ingenious compromise between size and performance with small defects 1Nikon D750 SLR Digital Camera (24.3 megapixels, 8.1 cm (3.2 inch) display, HDMI, USB 2.0) body only (Electronics) Good compromise between splash and crisp fried foodKüchenprofi 0808052829 Splatter Deluxe 29 cm (household goods) Good compromise between size and stability.Sony SEL-P1650 E lens E PZ 16-50 mm f / 3.5-5.6 OSS (Accessories) Very good compromise between DSLR and compact cameraPanasonic Lumix DMC-GM1 System camera (16 megapixels, 7.6 cm (3 inch) display, Full HD, optical image stabilization, WiFi) (Electronics) Compromise between speed and accuracyBraun 609337 Thermometer PRT 2000 Age Precision (Personal Care) A good compromise between European and Korean MMOAion: The Tower of Eternity (DVD-ROM)