big, heavy, slow, loud, but visually without alternatives in the Canon world

big, heavy, slow, loud, but visually without alternatives in the Canon world

Tokina AT-X 16-28mm / F2.8 Pro FX Wide Angle Zoom Lens for Canon lens mount (Electronics)

Customer Review

I would not get into the picture quality for long, because the will (photzone.de example) in several reviews extensively described and praised. Only I would like to join the local results: visually there for / of Canon no alternative !! Not even the new 16-35 f4 IS (Samyang maybe when a manual focus does not bother) The definition of the Tokina is a class of its own!

Even when working with there is nothing wrong, and I feel both zoom and focus as unnecessarily stiff and not smooth. The switchover from AF to MF not thrilled me, but you can live with it.

Unfortunately, the key to good super wide angle image quality seems to be the huge curved front lens. This makes the lens heavy, large, impractical (the cover can not you just quickly in your pocket insert) and the use of filters almost impossible. This latter event is at wide angle already a problem.

At first I thought that I do not care whether 600g (Canon) or 1kg (Tokina), but then I realized that the by no means so. You think about it always twice if one takes the lens genuine.

The two star points deduct two things:
- The reverse compared to Canon lenses zoom direction. That's a No !!
- The quite slow and noisy focus motor. For videographers definitely the lens is useless. Tokina not ashamed, nor to make the AF also advertising. What a crock, a Canon USM plays in a completely different galaxy. Super wide angle or not - what is so difficult about building a USM in such an expensive lens a ??

I have my Tokina 16-28 used less than a year on the EOS 6D and then sold. There is currently no successor.

Related Reviews


Light and shadow, but almost without alternativePentax SMC DA 16-50mm / F2.8 (IF) SDM Lens (Standard Zoom, waterproof) for Pentax (Electronics) A little big / Heavy ultra well but walkingThermos Stainless hammered effect 1 liter (Kitchen) Slower, louder and harder to clean than the AltmodellBosch food processor MUM48R1 MUM4 (600 watts, 3.9 liter, stainless steel mixing bowl, food processor, recipes DVD) red (household goods) pretty, but acts without pillar in the garden not so good.Venus stone figure stone cast Antique White Expensive but visually and good of the light outputOsram 73133 LED Noxlite Spot 8 W Outdoor Lamp (Garden & Outdoors) nice and loud - but does not fit under the doorAlarm Doorstop LED battery control door security Security systems (Misc.) Beautiful and good sound. But not to forget about the outside world.Sony MDRV55L DJ Headphones - Blue (Electronics) very good alternative to the Canon LP-E6PowerPlanet LP-E6 LP E6 (3347B001AA) Battery for CANON EOS 5D Mk 2 EOS 5D Mk II, EOS 5D Mk III, 6D, 7D, 60D - Fully 100% compatible - costs on a charger (Electronics) Good headphones, but not without weaknesses!Sony MDR-10RBT wireless headset (Bluetooth, AAC codec) (Electronics) ... Loud, but what interests me the ...Philips HP6420 / 00 Satinelle, white / pink (Personal Care) quite nice, but not as good as the originalHasbro B0733100 - Monopoly - The National Board Game (Toy) Effective, but loud, trembling and without lightPhilips HP6523 / 02 Satin Soft Epilator (Health and Beauty) Inexpensive, a bit too loud, but simply to slowXILENCE COO-XPF120.TR case fan 120x25mm (Red LED) (Accessories) He has become even louder - but better?JBL Flip II portable powered stereo speakers (Bluetooth, NFC, bass reflex, microphone) White (Electronics) He has become even louder - but better than its predecessor?JBL Flip II portable powered stereo speakers (Bluetooth, NFC, Bass Reflex) (Electronics) Affordable entry smartphone, but there are alternatives ... * Update *Huawei Ascend Y530 Smartphone (11.4 cm (4.5 inch) touchscreen, 5 megapixel camera, 4GB internal memory, Android 4.3) (Electronics) Recommended, but not without concernsCorsair Vengeance M95 gaming mouse black (Accessories) Design, function - though not without alternativeSony LHP1.SYH sun visor for DSC-RX1 Cyber-shot Camera (Electronics) Nice touch, but not without flawsApple MD564ZM / A USB SuperDrive DVD burner (8x DVDA ± R DL / 6x DVDA ± R DL / 6x DVDA ± RW / CD-R 24x / 16x CD-RW) (Personal Computers)