Clumsy, just acceptable but stimulating.

Clumsy, just acceptable but stimulating.

French Melancholy (Paperback)

Customer Review

Fine example of biter! Eric Zemmour, so cruel and direct in his criticism "literary", seems to have a little sloppy yet a book that does not lack breath.
Views of its construction (cutting in arbitrary chapters acrobatic overview of our history), the style (p 153. "They ignore the pacifist ... that fascinated to Hitler's Germany far as they had taken of empathy for that of Stresemann ';' oufff) and the clarity of his statement (p 150: ". the famous> French pushes the French political theater in a move to ... ostracize . "'' Ouuupppps !!!), many would resume; Examples like these are too many! And a careful reader can only continue against the heart annoyed his reading.
The only reasons to persevere is the tone and pitch of view of reflection, and also the unusual theses based on a striking historical scholarship, surprising even in one of those journalists today, the temptation heartbreaking is to write about everything, anything, anyhow, after exhausting their ability to play "Lady Sun" about the news.
The impression remains unfinished, insufficient rigor, as if the author, "doctus cum libro" but confused, had not managed to master a large and solid documentation or to draw fluid and book Clearly, not having "a hundred times on the loom, ...". Too rushed, Mr. Zemmour, but interesting 'still ...

Related Reviews


Comparable acceptable, but no longer with the Case for the iPhone 4Twelve South BookBook Case for Apple iPhone 5 / 5S brown (Wireless Phone Accessory) Good acceptance - but for 35 minutes chewing fun quite expensive ....8in1 Delights Bones Strong, healthy chew with high quality chicken for extra strong chewing dogs, size L (Misc.) For children just great, but also for seniors a nice idea !!!RAVENSBURGER Paint by Numbers CHOICE Various subjects CLASSIC SERIES NEW (Toys) Possibly just unlucky, but unfortunately these heads do not meet the promised quality of philiphsPhilips Sonicare HX6018 / 07 ProResults brush head standard, 8-pack (Personal Care) Acceptable, but not good ...Nikon WU-1a - Wireless transmitter for mobile (Camera Photos) Acceptable, but only on propane bottle.Einhell GS 4600/2333200 Gas Heating Power adjustable from 2.7 to 4.6 kW Working pressure 50 mbar (Tools & Accessories) Acceptable but misses topicKontor House of House - Winter Edition 2015 (MP3 Download) To icebraker do not need much to say, just good but not cheapIcebreaker Men Vest T-Shirt Short Sleeve Anatomica Crewe (Sports Apparel) As Küchenradio just OK but too expensive.Philips BTM2056 / 12 Micro system (2x 7.5 watts RMS, CD / MP3 / WMA, Bluetooth, RDS, USB) Silver (Electronics) Sigg is just great, butSigg Water Bottle Traveller (equipment) Hums even on the lowest level - not acceptable - but an eye-catcher!AEG T-VL 5537 Tower fan with remote control, stainless steel (tool) Fissler - just good, but not cheapFissler original pro collection® stainless steel serving pan, non-stick sealed, 32 cm, without lid (household goods) Quality just good, but not very good.adidas Men DFB jersey Home 4 Stars (Sports Apparel) Fresh, cheeky, Sarah Connor - just Naughty but NiceNaughty But Nice (Audio CD) Looks just fine but worthless.LCS - ORION - 2M - Ultra HD 4K - New version HDMI cable 2.0 / 1.4a compatible - Triple shielding - 3D - ARC - CEC - 1080p / 2160p (Electronics) Acceptable, but that's about it.Zalman ZM-MIC1 microphone Micro Hook (Personal Computers) Fresh, cheeky, Sarah Connor - just Naughty but Nice 1Naughty But Nice (Limited Digipack Edition) (Audio CD) Value for money for me even just ok but not really good.Grundig 40 VLE 5421 BG 100 cm (40 inch) LED backlight TVs (Full HD, 200Hz PPR, DVB-T / C / S2, 3x HDMI, 2x USB) (Electronics) Not just bad, but not what is expected ..HP Officejet 7500A e-All-in-One inkjet multifunction printer (A3, printer, scanner, copier, fax, wireless, Ethernet, USB, 4800x1200) (Personal Computers)