A historian open about faith?

A historian open about faith?

Jesus (Paperback)

Customer Review

A new book on Jesus, but Jesus from the perspective "historical character"!

The obvious first question that comes to mind is that of the need for such a book. What is there again that justified this new release? What can it bring and to whom? I am afraid that after reading also remains skeptical than before ... this book is not likely to move the borders of a iota! As usual for this kind of work he has great chances of interest only to people already convinced.

Jesus "historic figure" who can still deny it? But wanting to expand this character, try to give it more historical consistency, is that really what's important? It seems to me that much more interested the majority of potential readers of such books would be first if it was possible or feasible, the historical study of the passage of this character of the state of "Jewish prophet" the proclaimed state of "son of God" by a nascent religious community, and it would then, and especially the study of the original content of the message of this "messiah" on the one hand and on the other hand, the This content transformation process into a set of dogmas, and this in a historical and religious conflict environment.

That said, once the framework defined as such by the author of the "historical" Jesus, one can not escape a series of recurring questions when a book addresses this very sensitive issue: can we, as a historian, grant such importance to the canonical Gospels, and consider them as reliable historical sources, while many of these writers were only second-hand collectors, especially those editors were heavily involved in the various Christian communities very activists of the time? ... and why favor the gospel of John says over other while it is the latest? Are less reliable because others considered more "primitive"? On the other hand minimize the differences between these gospels, if only on the aspect of "continuity / rupture" with respect to Jewish religious law, and seem to surrender some rationalism due to any scientific approach when the key field the supernatural, is that it can actually give confidence to the reader? What to think what disturbed reader when he reads in an interview with the author ... "My book is a book of historian but a historian open on faith, the miracle"?

One of those books I therefore take care not to recommend for or against both the expectations of readers can be diverse ...

Finally a -always here -... Rank: 5/5
July 10
Successful entry Smartphone Rank: 5/5
June 12
Perfect January 2084 Rank: 5/5
April 14
perfect 1 4164 Rank: 5/5
June 17
Very good! January 2850 Rank: 5/5
April 19
Very satisfied 312 2 Rank: 4/5
October 10

Related Reviews


Doubt about doubtDoubt (Amazon Instant Video) Maybe something about dustBallistic Hard Core BLHCI4BK Case for Apple iPhone 4 / 4S Black (Wireless Phone Accessory) All in all, a worthy conclusion to this trilogy RecommendedAllegiant (Divergent Series, Volume 3) (Paperback) Airy timeless SoulFaithful Man [Vinyl] (Vinyl) The anger is still thereThe Battle of Los Angeles (Audio CD) Send protective case with room for improvementPlemo Nylon Lycra fabric Case Cover Sleeve for 38.1 to 39.6 cm Briefcase (15 to 15.6 inches) laptop / notebook computer / MacBook / MacBook Pro, Black (Electronics) A great telescope for beginnersCelestron NexStar SLT 127 Telescope (Electronics) Design error - flap does not closeROCK "Delight" Sony Xperia Z3 Premium Leather Case Cover Case in Book Style - gold (electronics) An Excellent Autobiography befitting Its TitleOpen: An Autobiography (Hardcover) Not bad, but .. 31Bomann KG 183 White Fridge-freezer / A +++ / 180 cm height / 131 kWh / year / 176 L refrigerator / freezer 65 L / adjustable thermostat / door opening (Misc.) Slightly sensitive mouse for large handsHAVITĀ® HV MS924GT 6-button wireless optical mouse, 2.4GHz, up to 10 meters range, (gray + black), Easter (Personal Computers) very well-made laptop bag - very discreetly - and a clever featureThink Tank Retrospective 15L Pinestone Cotton Canvas Laptop Case (Camera) Send versatile protective pouch with weakness in the corner and edge protectionDICOTA SmartSkin for 39.6 cm 15.6 inch notebooks (Accessories) Is serving - but not qualityProfessional Sommelier corkscrew lever bottle opener (household goods) Very nice transportable trunkPlaymobil - 5167 - Construction game - Transportable House (Toy) Reliably GoodThe Children Act (Hardcover) for starters, it isThe guide sexual willy (Board) A new world 1Real Thing, the (CD) EngagingWinter Journal (Paperback)