Fantastic music, but exhausting instrument

Fantastic music, but exhausting instrument

Bach: Goldberg Variations (Audio CD)

Customer Review

For his recordings of classical music, especially Bach's works, Keith Jarrett has indeed have plenty of take criticism. Especially with the "Goldberg Variations" purists put the bar very high, and many both Glenn Gould recordings from 1955 and 1981 are assumed to be the measure of all things. Jarrett, the tenor of the criticism, interpret the music does not (what else indeed masterfully dominant in his own free improvisation), but only play good notes on what was inconsistent with the spirit of Bach's music. In addition to classical music was not his genre and you feel just at the "Goldberg Variations" painful.
It must be said: How exactly Johann Sebastian Bach to the sound of his work presented, or as he himself has interpreted at the harpsichord or the piano, we do not know. The number of recordings from the Baroque period is more manageable. There is also for comparison with Gould neither harpsichord recording of the "Goldberg Variations" of Canadian exceptional pianist nor a corresponding piano version of Jarrett. Simila similibus conferantur!
The "Goldberg Variations" are wonderfully composed music and, if they are played by a rounder, already wonderful to listen per se. Whether there now in nuances one way or another variation a little more intense or gentle or "superficial" is interpreted, this is more of an academic question. The problem that I have with this CD, is not the composition or their interpretation by Jarrett, but rather the instrument. The "Goldberg Variations" have been composed for the harpsichord, certainly, but I'm piano music more ear than the longer duration but something "hard" sound of the harpsichord. A matter of taste, I know, but it is still a criterion for me.

Tom Tom Via 135 M Rank: 1/5
July 7
Enjoy it! 2 Rank: 5/5
November 24
Finally something that works 1 Rank: 5/5
October 22
Very nice 140 4 Rank: 4/5
February 12

Related Reviews


fantastic music, unfortunately, usually shortenedPoland (Remastered 2CD Edition) (Audio CD) Good music, but ....The Hunger Games - Mockingjay Part 1 (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) (MP3 Download) Sublime music but cheap presentationNevermind (Remastered) Deluxe Version [Vinyl] (Vinyl) Good music but no soundtrack!The Hunger Games - Catching Fire (Deluxe Edition) (MP3 Download) Evocative music - but somehow always the sameTales from Africa (Audio CD) No music from the plastic box, but acoustic instruments and musical from around the worldWe Children From Kleist Park (Audio CD) fantastic game - fantastic musicFinal Fantasy X (Audio CD) Great music, but the sound!Blues Pills [Vinyl] (Vinyl) Fantastic music - Remastering misses the pointIrish Tour (Audio CD) Pretty good radio play finally again convincing music but unfortunately brillant end.154 / Embassy of the Unterwel (Audio CD) artistic super but quite instrumental to improveVirtuoso (Audio CD) I love this musical, but ...Rent (Audio CD) Grandiose music but unnecessary and unsuccessful remake of the CD "The Singles Collection 1981-93"The Very Best Of (Audio CD) Beautiful music - but not quite as good as soundtrack Number 1 ...24: Seasons Four & Five (Audio CD) Great music, but loveless implementation of Virgin18 Greatest Hits (Audio CD) but very instrumentalRuby Red (Audio CD) A masterpiece with extremely good lyrics and fantastic music !!!A Gifted Day (Audio CD) Fantastic music for the senses!I Choose Noise (Audio CD) Very good music - but that's still a trance?We Are All We Need (Audio CD)