Masterpiece despite logic gaps

Masterpiece despite logic gaps

Hyperion (Hyperion Cantos) (Paperback)

Customer Review

Hyperion is a masterpiece, no doubt (am now after "The Fall of Hyperion" in "Emdymion - gates of time" arrived).

Atmorsphärisch and linguistically excellent, the only thing that bothers me are some blunders in terms of logic.

Spoiler:

1. The Shrike must be prevented from spreading in the world power (hegemony), because this could mean the end of humanity.

- Then why are 7 pilgrims with personal concerns the solution to stop it?
- What particularly bothers me because: Each of the pilgrims to the Shrike recite a personal wish, which it met, whereas the other 6 Pilgrims land on the tree of thorns.
- Hide to a personal request (removal of Kruziform, fulfillment of the poem, etc.) stop the Shrike ??? This circumstance gives no sense and was also recognized by Dan Simmons probably because this idea is not pursued on arrival at the Time Tombs. The only wish would make the point would be to say: "Stop trying to be to eradicate the hegemony and thus humanity."

2. The Death Ray (The secret weapon of the Techno Core in Volume 2).

- When the Techno Core is so infinitely far developed and able to fake a complete Ousterinvasion, how can it be that the Techno Core - to use this weapon must at length persuaded Gladstone them - on AI consultant?
- Why not just themselves to push the button? The people who should survive in the labyrinth worlds as neurons source, could have carried it there and elsewhere.

SPOILER END

These two questions concern myself with respect to the Hyperion Cantos much because it (if I have not made a mistake himself) already deemed legal blunders of logic.

Or can someone enlighten me :)?

Immaculate screen protectors Rank: 5/5
February 12
Not again 3 2 Rank: 1/5
October 9
Handle with care! Rank: 4/5
October 21
"The" Bluetooth adapter !!! Rank: 5/5
February 22
very good buy 335 Rank: 5/5
June 7
4 delivery problem Rank: 2/5
November 10

Related Reviews


Masterpiece despite some quirksAssassin's Creed (video game) Good game with a logic gap and occasional hangersAssassin's Creed [Platinum] (Video Game) Masterpiece with some gapsOut of the Dark (Audio CD) Madden with old gapsMadden NFL 25 - [Xbox 360] (Video Game) With sword and flame breath against evilDivinity II - Ego Draconis [Download] (Software Download) Freedom for the new worldAssassins Creed III (computer game) Great pictures, story unfortunately "Kin-Topp"Lucy (Amazon Instant Video) Exciting KatastrophenfilmInto the Storm (Blu-ray) Very exciting episode with some fresh ideas.170 / road of horror (Audio CD) Screenwriter was a zombie ...The Walking Dead - Season 1 (Amazon Instant Video) On discovery through Mordor with Talion Bruce AltairMiddle-earth: Shadow of Mordor - [PlayStation 4] (Video Game) A good overall impression, which is strong but marred by the last 10 minutesMass Effect 3 - [Xbox 360] (Video Game) Exceptional, well playable ThrillerLA Noire (uncut) - [PlayStation 3] (Video Game) Title selection OK, sound quality out of the questionThe Very Best of the Beach Boys (Audio CD) Unique 2 JuneThe Wheel of Time, Book 15: The path of daggers (Paperback) Gruselfim beautiful, reminiscent of old timesThe Nun (Amazon Instant Video) TKKG - The Internet adventurers187 / Spied! (Audio CD) Promising approaches and filling material are balanced.Two Eleven (Deluxe Version) (Audio CD) 18 firecrackers and two new - piecemeal, but indispensable!Then and Now-Best of (Audio CD)