Really not that great as its predecessor

Really not that great as its predecessor

Earth Songs (Audio CD)

Customer Review

Secret Garden was for me one of the rediscoveries of 2004. All of their albums to date would include my "Desert Iceland" collection.
There was great expectation on this new CD, and since it was in Germany as long as I have it ordered from Amazon USA.
The trend I confirm the comments of the previous candidates: Nice to beautiful, but the spark of enthusiasm is blocked by something.
Rolf and Fionnula have some of the pieces on this new CD with a little too much ambition, if I may say so, written and designed and overloaded with it. This is especially true for "Half the World Away", where the vocal is then taken over almost operatic ripe of a "trained" male voice. - Not my case. Or perhaps a little artificially acting instruments such as Bach trumpet.
Secret Garden for me are at their best when they are based on the folk and there is then on this CD some real masterpieces: "Sleep Song" (a dream), "The Reel" (exciting - I have the world premiere of this piece in Sydney witnessed), "Lotus" (dreamy exotic with the guest appearance of a Chinese erhu player), "Daughters of Erin" (beautiful "Irish").
The hymns sung are certainly pathetic ("Always there" & "Raise your voices"), but already one knows from the previous CDs and probably belongs to the temperament of thoughtful Norwegian Rolf Lovland as composers. I personally like these pieces really.
Some wrote that 3 pieces are more on the Norwegian version. True, I have seen in Oslo, but unfortunately the CD there is also twice as expensive as here.
By the way, I was recently in Shanghai and since I got this CD a beautiful Collectors Box with a separate DVD about the making of the album as well as the Chinese version of "Always there" - and all at a regular price (no predatory pressure) of 6 80 EUR !!!!!!
But back to the contents of this CD.
The booklet for the CD is as always well decorated and informative. You can learn everything about the background of the pieces and the respective musicians. May indeed be somewhat conservative, but I would hope that I would have such booklets to more CDs of other artists.
My résumé: Certainly one of the weaker CDs of Secret Garden, but still worth buying and worlds better than many other (highly praised) "scrap" of other artists

Super power supply! 1 Rank: 5/5
November 8
Bombastic action experience Rank: 5/5
November 6
Superboard, am thrilled Rank: 5/5
August 16
Excellent 96 Rank: 4/5
April 4
A little disappointed 73 1 Rank: 2/5
February 14
Good gift idea 2 1 Rank: 4/5
March 19

Related Reviews


Really not that great.Zewa Soft toilet paper "The Best", 16 rolls (Personal Care) Fit is not that great ...Rupse Automotive tailpipe exhaust tailpipe tailpipe tailpipe chromed steel silver Great game that does not share much with its predecessors luckilyAssassin's Creed IV: Black Flag - Digital Deluxe [PC Download] (Software Download) Not quite as great as its predecessor, but still an atmospheric Schlachtplatte.Dead Space 2 (Video Game) Unfortunately not as good as its predecessorsRadio Maria (Audio CD) Not for lovers of its predecessorSony MDR-1AS High Resolution headphones (40mm high definition driver units) Silver (Electronics) Works well but the service is not that greatSony ICD-PX333 digital voice recorder 4GB (300mW output, MP3, card slot, USB, integrated mono microphone + connection for external microphone) (Office supplies & stationery) Solid but not as quiet as its predecessorEheim 2071020 External filter professionel 3 250 with filter media (Misc.) Unfortunately not as catchy as its predecessorThe Hobbit - The Desolation of Smaug (Deluxe Edition) (Audio CD) Not as strong as its predecessorOmen (Deluxe Edition) (Audio CD) Quite good but not as good as its predecessorsAshes of the Wake (Audio CD) Served its purpose but is visually not that greatmobile: instyle Black Cystal Case for Samsung S5230 (Accessories) Great game, but not much different than its predecessor.The Sims 4 (computer game) Not many improvements to its predecessor, yet highly recommendedFar Cry 4 - Limited Edition - [Playstation 3] (Video Game) Not to compare with its predecessorNine Destinies And A Downfall (Audio CD) Unfortunately, the successor is not always better than its predecessor ...Udo Walz by Beurer HC7 200 hair trimmer (Personal Care) Not as nice as its predecessorCanon Pixma IP110 Mobile Inkjet (9600 x 2400 dpi, USB, WiFi, Pixma Cloud Link, Apple AirPrint) black (accessories) Good, but not as good as its predecessorAlly McBeal For Once In My Life (Audio CD) Optical class quality not that great eitherMustard Book Lamp Tiny Tim, red, NG6008R (tool)