Successful Comeback of a true all-star prog band

Successful Comeback of a true all-star prog band

The Whirlwind Ltd.2cd + DVD (Audio CD)

Customer Review

I was, like many others, very excited about the CD. What we have to wait and already have doubts about the hope of a 3rd studio CD of the band. The people behind the project I have the inclined prospective here safely say nothing. Of course, all 4 musicians are certain exceptional talents, and very successful in their regular bands (Marillion, Dream Theater, Flower Kings, ex-Spock's Beard - now solo ... who knows ...?!). All these bands I knew a long time, long before Transatlantic. And now the 3rd work of this reunion, because for a long time (also because of religious thought - I miss my own band jammer * *) a comeback was unthinkable.
One song, "The Whirlwind", exactly 78 minutes long, divided into suites with repeatedly returning motives. It begins with a noise, and ends very glorious and sublime. Personally, I could not have wished a better Progrockalbum. Although sounds here and there through times that the recording and writing sessions are much too unusual scarce, but that does not detract from the overall picture; at least not for me. Sometimes there are lengths, sometimes lack the element of surprise, but I'm so surprised enough already :) Seriously, I think it's probably one of the most important and best-PROG albums of the year ... and that was when it comes to progressive rock eh a very good year.
I recommend buying the CD, and rate to the deluxe edition, since the "making-of" the enclosed DVD (total 105 minutes interesting ... you have something to long images to the vocal recordings verschmerze) is made very informative and nice ,
The bonus disc is certainly a nice complement to the whole. Of particular note is an absolutely grandiose cover of "The Return Of The Giant Hogweed" of Genesis (Nursery Cryme, 1971). The bonus songs of the band are great, although much popiger ... but I also like sweet melodies.

My recommendation: Buy! If you like prog, who finds good Spock's Beard and Flower Kings ... here you doing nothing wrong. 4 musicians on very high level.

For me, probably the prog album of the year.

Segr good edge protection Rank: 5/5
October 31
Further comments are überflüssig- Rank: 5/5
September 12
A good idea, but ... Rank: 3/5
May 19
Angel or demon? 1 Rank: 3/5
September 28
First in the class! Rank: 5/5
May 24

Related Reviews


Successful ComebackTaking Chances (Audio CD) converse all starConverse CTAS Core Hi, Trainers Unisex Fashion (Clothing) Louis Armstrong & His All Stars live in Berlin in 1965The Legendary Berlin Concert (Audio CD) Good radio with CD / USB function for little money, a true all-rounder with good soundLenco SCD-37 Portable FM radio with CD player (USB 2.0) orange (Electronics) All Stars is always goodAll Stars Whey Protein, Cookies-Cream, 1er Pack (1 x 500 g bag) (Health and Beauty) All Stars Hy-Pro Deluxe Coconut Pineapple, mmmmmmmmmhhhh how delicious!All Stars Hy-Pro Deluxe bag Cocos pineapple, 1er Pack (1 x 500 g) (Health and Beauty) Louis Armstrong & His All Stars live in Berlin in 1965, part 2The Legendary Berlin Concert, Part II (Audio CD) One-sentence review: Sonic & SEGA All-Stars RacingSonic & SEGA All-Stars Racing (Video Game) A true all-rounder!Nivea Creme Care Intensive Care 100 ml, 4-pack (4 x 100 ml)) (Health and Beauty) Very successful comeback of old starsLike a Love Song (Audio CD) Small but nice - True Five StarPerixx Periboard-804II DE Bluetooth keyboard (up to 10 meters range, on / off switch, Li-Ion battery, Android capable QWERTY layout) Black (Personal Computers) Successful comeback albumShakira. (Deluxe Version) (Audio CD) All StarsRosenstein & Söhne Cakepop-maker for 12 delicious Miniküchlein Tanners successful comebackDriver: San Francisco (Video Game) A must for all Star Wars fansStar Wars - The Force Unleashed: Ultimate Sith Edition [Software Pyramide] (computer game) Successful comeback of blow-dried hairOnce around the world (Ltd) (Audio CD) All-Star Album made by the Ruff Ryders!Ryde or Die - Vol 1 (Audio CD). A true all-rounder and absolute KlangmeisterSony MDR-V55 / BR DJ Headphones - Red (Electronics) Successful comeback - but not quite as good as the successorWe'll Bring the House Down (Audio CD)