First impression: great dishes! Here is great, I like to eat in a real plate, having a real mug, not half a mug.
In short, it is great.
The look: red thread can pass. It would look great with gingham napkins, bucolic picnic. It's not my trip for dishes everyday I like going everywhere, but we made it. It remains to see the prices precisely.
The finish: It's not the Limoges porcelain. It does not diminish the possibility to eat or drink. Again, the price will determine whether or not, the finish is up. As first prize, we do not attach too much (and still is not a reason to do the job badly).
Fairly positive, assuming that it is a first prize. It will be a little more challenging with rising prices.