Looking for a game like me then encountered "The Lost Island", which wandered into my cart, mainly due to the positive reviews and the moderate price. Another plus for me: the game is playable for two.
First impression when unpacking: The game material is really beautiful and atmospherically designed appropriately. The flood and artifact cards could perhaps be a little thicker, but otherwise I'm very satisfied with the processing and presentation. So read quickly in the rules (rather simple rules, understandable Instructions) and losgelegt.
The game is really fun! One has to ponder a bit and coordinate, because before you know sichs, sink parts of the island in the sea routes are cut off and the artifacts threaten lost forever to go. Especially the "The tide is rising! Cards" bring excitement to the game, because the pace draws significantly on.
As it is with the game after multiple playthrough, I can not say yet, but so far I'm very impressed. :)