Worse than "Twilight" and "Eclipse" better than "Breaking Dawn"

Worse than "Twilight" and "Eclipse" better than "Breaking Dawn"

New Moon (Paperback)

Customer Review

While I wrote my recession to "Twilight", I searched for the right words to sum up, what happened to me when I read. Now, after I read "New Moon" for the second time, I found it.

I have lost myself in the books. I could drop me completely in the story and everything else to hide.
An effect which is unfortunately no longer occurred during the second passage.

When I read "New Moon" for the first time, I was still so under the spell of this fantasy world that I was just as excited as the first volume. But now, I see it a little differently.
"New" Moon lacks what "Twilight" clearly identified - much Edward and Bella.
Early on in the band are Bella's feelings no longer heartbreaking, but simply just annoying. About halfway through the book one would you most like to slap, in order to persuade them to awaken from their stupor.
Only in the last pages did "New Moon" meets the expectations I had when I bought the book.

Just like "Twilight" the story is again relatively simple one and (if you consider that there are two more volumes) predictable.
The characters who have inspired me in "Twilight" fill to the in "New Moon" only about a third, rather less, the book.

Conclusion - This book is worth reading, is / but is uninteresting when the "magic" of the Twilight saga has evaporated or, if you have the "magic" never experienced.

Three stars there are, as I New Moon not so bad was how "Breaking Dawn", but not as good as "Eclipse".

As if you were there! 2 Rank: 4/5
July 29
Attention to marketplace Rank: 1/5
November 10
I order regularly Rank: 5/5
December 7
From mother to daughter Rank: 5/5
August 30
English German Dictionary Offline Rank: 4/5
October 19

Related Reviews


Well ... no better and no worse than no-name productsMelitta 178599 Cleaning Tablets Kaffeevollautomaten PerfectClean Espresso 4 Tabs (household goods) better and worse than Part 1Crysis 2 - Limited Edition (Uncut) (Video Game) No better and no worse than other MaschinendeosFinish Spülmaschinendeo Odour Stop, 5-pack (5 x 1 piece) (Health and Beauty) Autofocus is hell, image quality worse than predecessors. Annual marketing strategy between Canon, Nikon and Sony.?Nikon Coolpix P600 Digital Camera (16 Megapixel, 60x optical Mega Zoom with Super ED glass, 7.5 cm (3 inches) RGBW LCD monitor 5-axis image stabilization (VR), Dynamic Fine Zoom, Wi -Fi) (Electronics) Better / worse than BF3 ???Battlefield 4 - Deluxe Edition (Exclusive to Amazon.de) (Video Game) Outdoor: slightly better | Indoor: worse than the internal micro RX100iiSony ECMXYST1M.CE7 stereo microphone for Camcorder with Multi Interface Shoe accessories (Accessories) Worse neck, back and headaches than beforeNeck pillows, cushions, pillows, neck support pillows, health pillows - from molded foam - orthopedic - (household goods) Not better or worse than the songs from the standard albumHanging by a thread - Under the skin version (digipack) (Audio CD) Does the job and the better than expectedPanasonic NN-E229MMEPG solo microwave / 700 watts / 19 L oven / mechanical operation / white (Misc.) Lost Planet 3 - even worse than the previous Lost Planet 2?Lost Planet 3 - [Xbox 360] (Video Game) Worse than VW CockpitspraySONAX Cockpit Cleaner Matt Effect 02832410 XTREME (Automotive) Worse than the original battery (supplied with the S3 Mini) !!! "CELL MADE IN KOREA ASSEMBLED IN VIETNAM"Samsung EB-F1M7FLUCSTD Battery for Samsung Galaxy S3Mini (1500 mAh) (Accessories) Worse than IXUS 220HSCanon Ixus 155 Compact digital camera 20 megapixel LCD Monitor 2.7 "Optical Zoom 10X Silver (Camera Photos) Worse than the chipset of my notebook ...Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Go Pro - USB Sound Card - SBX ProStudio (Accessory) Worse than the first 1Near you (Hardcover) Worse than before ... 1Sennheiser MX 375 Earphone player foam end caps + + Cover Kit (Electronics) Worse than any cell phone cameraCanon IXUS 132 digital camera (16 megapixel, 8x opt. Zoom, 6.9 cm (2.7 inch) display, image stabilized) Silver (Electronics) Warning, the remaster sounds worse than the original!In Utero (20th Anniversary Remaster) (Audio CD) No worse than the 1.4Sony SAL-50F18 1.8 / 50mm Sony SAM portrait lens (optional)