Graphics: The graphics are nice and the game runs even on old computers still well and smoothly. The pluses are! The graph therefore gets 4 points. There is a point deduction because the graphics by today's standards is indeed good, but not outstanding.
Atmosphere: A game with such a great atmosphere there are rare. The Lord of the Rings feeling comes on immediately, above all, because the graphics are also very good. The landscapes are also make very nice and loving! Therefore, 5 points!
Sound: I need not say much about the sound, which is great. Since there are also 5 points. The music is breathtaking! Very very good soundtrack, the music used in the game.
Scope: The Collector's Edition to get a special unit for online Gameing, a beautiful and quite thick description book, a poster with the good and evil campaign. Only everything is in English, so beware. Also the game is in English, so there are only 4 points. But you can get the German language for the game in a about 500MB large file.
Conclusion: All together it's a great game, there is only little quirks. I would buy in its place the Collectors Edition, because there are also still all the videos of the campaign and a lot more here. So, grab on, the so a good game into a film series, there is not!