I can only judge as ordinary consumers and give no craftsmanship statement. I liked / like Edith Piaf, therefore I am happy that their most famous songs have been re-recorded with Mireille Mathieu. Just great, the voice of this small big woman. It is an "ear candy" for me. If you like the French language and Edith Piaf, comes with this CD their money's worth, I can only recommend the appropriate admirers. US