I can only recommend this fodder, like all Happy Dog products. All dogs in the family get Happy Dog and all are top fit. Lotte has also from time to hiccups, but that does not come from eating. Puppies that have often times, or if they're cold after eating. She takes the dry food also like as a treat and has never found fault. Whether we then stay with the NaturCroque We do not know yet, but we are simply times make a feed sample.