Shapiro is not Austen

Shapiro is not Austen

Sanditon: Jane Austen's Unfinished Masterpiece Completed (Paperback)

Customer Review

The pleasure of reading of Austen spoiled here by the Working MMe Shapiro. I'm sure her when she rewrote and completed the novel, was honorable, but it is obvious that Ms. Shapiro has no style, imagination and the capacity romantic architect Jane Austen possessed.

I reproach, above all, to this reconstruction, the soliloquy of Charlotte, who swear with all Austen ever wrote.

Reading this novel is sometimes touching, but never satisfactory.

really sucks Rank: 1/5
April 11
Devours Rank: 4/5
May 7
very well in January 1514 Rank: 5/5
December 15
Better than "Bought seen as" Rank: 5/5
December 2

Related Reviews


Mixed review, pleasant reading, but it is not Jane AustenThe daughters of Mr Darcy (Paperback) We have not finished rediscover Jane AustenRevue des deux Mondes, May 2013: Why is the best Jane Austen (Paperback) Jane Austen is not betrayed ...Charlotte Collins (Paperback) No it is not Jane AustenThe daughters of Mr Darcy (Paperback) Jane Austen do not forget to listen to Reason and FeelingsSense and Sensibility (Paperback) Unfortunately not as good as the first part.For You Alone (Paperback) Nix for Austen fans!Mr. Darcy's Diary (Paperback) Not the best newspaperThe newspaper Mr Knightley (Paperback) Essential for fans of Jane AustenSense and Sensibility (Penguin Classics Deluxe Edition) (Paperback) romantic but not cutesySense and Sensibility (Paperback) Of all the novels of Jane Austen is the one who offers the widest range of characters must .... TestimonySense and Sensibility (Paperback) a nice time in the land of Jane AustenCharlotte Collins (Paperback) I really enjoyed myself with this novel that I recommend to all fans of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice orCharlotte Collins (Paperback) A detective novel about Victorian background, on the border between Anne Perry and Jane AustenOf particular interest to the dead (Paperback) A nod very supported and highly successful Jane Austen fans - especially those of Darcy!Maid in Austenland (Paperback) Great for fans of Austen!The lost manuscript by Jane Austen (Paperback) a safe bet, but not my favoriteThe Annotated Northanger Abbey (Paperback) Austen version amusement park for adult women.Maid in Austenland (Paperback) Tribute to Jane AustenThe daughters of Mr Darcy (Paperback)