Schumann Symphonies by Wolfgang Sawallisch in Dresden: fluidity, balance and lyricism

Schumann Symphonies by Wolfgang Sawallisch in Dresden: fluidity, balance and lyricism

Schumann: The 4 Symphonies - Openings - Scherzo & Finale (CD)

Customer Review

This integral recorded in the early 1970s by Wolfgang Sawallisch was always admired by his unifying virtues felt perfectly approach end and generously stamped orchestra, all led by strong and inspired leadership that obscures transient "heaviness" of works.

Only the sound seems detrimental to full sharpness of the lines: Lukaskirche the church's generous acoustic basses liquefies the scansion and sometimes gives the orchestra the rumor of an organ, which affects the rebound the allegro and scherzo.
However, the slow movement of the "Second" finds a heavenly sound.

The symphony Spring has fruity stamps Staatskapelle, which subtly animates the four pastoral paintings.

In the "Rhenish", agility limitless Dresdeners desks allows a final of unsurpassed virtuosity. The very prompt baton of German conductor raises the speed that takes Mercurial work in a scintillating choreography.
Proponents of a darker approach should refer to the version of Carlo-Maria Giulini with the Philharmonia (EMI).

In the "Fourth" the light texture of the orchestra Saxon similarly takes this opus to the big day than to the mysterious shadows that characterize the dark romanticism What débusquait Furtwängler.
His Germanic misty climate is dissipated by radiant approach whose vitality will not leave anyone indifferent.

If you have to choose among the full commendable, it is always necessary in the lead pack.
But do not forget the classic supercilious George Szell in Cleveland (CBS) nor the authentic flavor of the Leipzig Gewandhaus under the baton of Franz Konwitschny (Berlin Classics).
In another aesthetic: the ardor of Leonard Bernstein and the New York Philharmonic shiny (CBS), less idiomatic but a seduction so tempting!
And if you love instrumental sumptuousness, the mellifluous Wiener Philharmoniker conducted by Georg Solti (Decca) awaits you.

Related Reviews


Schumann sometimes overlooked ...Schumann: The 4 Symphonies - Openings - Scherzo & Finale (CD) Schumann romantic and yet grippingSymphonies 1-4 / Overture / Scherzo and Finale (Audio CD) An orchestra, 11 conductors, 13 composers, 95 symphoniesVienna Philharmonic Symphony Edition (Limited Edition) (Audio CD) THE masterpiece of symphonic metalImaginaerum (2 CD) (CD) Wolfgang Petry "Brand New" and in top form!Brand (Audio CD) A day in the life of Wolfgang P. ...One More Time! (Audio CD) A must-have album for all Final Fantasy fans and lovers of symphonic music!Final Symphony - Music From Final Fantasy VI, VII and X (MP3 Download) A great cycle, but less homogeneous than they saySchumann: The 4 Symphonies - Openings - Scherzo & Finale (CD) Good use of a compact orchestrationSchumann: The 4 Symphonies - Openings - Scherzo & Finale (CD) The Brahms heartBrahms: Piano Concertos No. 1 & 2 (CD) A memorable fullSchumann: The 4 Symphonies - Openings - Scherzo & Finale (CD) One of the most recommendable diptychs, with superb supplementsBrahms: Piano Concertos No. 1 and No. 2 - Lieder Op 91 and 105 (CD). A lyrical and warm interpretation of Mendelssohn's orchestral workMendelssohn: Symphonies openings (CD) Hotter, the wotantissimeHans Hotter: The Wotan of the Century at His Best (CD) An exemplary project (it remains)2 Soviet Experience: String Quartets (CD) An amazing result!Anton Bruckner: Celibidache (12 CD Box Set) (CD) track listingClaudio Abbado: The RCA and Sony Album Collection (39 CD Box Set) (CD) A dream as old as the CD comes true!Toscanini Collection (CD) Klug Hardt 'Schilflieder' (and more) interpreted wisely, at the highest level ...Schilflieder (Audio CD)