The controversy comes only from the fact that one is a fan or a fan of Waters Gilmour.
Without going into this game, you aim to say that the latest titles for Floyd Waters, whether already in Animals in The Wall lose Love and Hope: these are songs (beautiful) but very dark that reveal anger of a man: Roger Waters ...
The problem is that The Final Cut in 1982, this anger is so strong (see song lyrics Not Now John) that the album loses its structure and the group separates.
At the age of 20 I listened to dozens of times throughout the work Pink Floyd: Piper at the Gates of Dawn Pulse and adding the solo albums each member Syd Barrett, Rick Wright Nick Mason, Roger Waters and David Gilmour.
The Division Bell is a true and Floyd opus is an album that people will enjoy discovering and re-listen!